View “My Mother’s Garden” Full Length Here

by Catherine MacDonald on June 9, 2009

Cynthia Lester left home at 13 years of age because she couldn’t find a place to sleep in the house amidst all of the garbage. Now an adult, she returns with her brothers to try to grapple with her mother’s hoarding and the house itself, which is stuffed with garbage, newspaper, and rodents. She chronicles the process in “My Mother’s Garden,” an award-winning documentary that you can watch, in full, below:

Part 1:

Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy

Part 2:

Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy

Part 3:

Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy

Part 4:

Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy

Part 5:

Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy

Part 6:

Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy

Part 7:

Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy

Epilogue:

Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy

You can read more about Cynthia Lester, her mother and “My Mother’s Garden” here.

What did you think of this documentary? Please leave your comments below.

{ 18 comments… read them below or add one }

julie c. June 13, 2009 at 9:40 pm

My dad was a hoarder, my brother was a hoarder, my mother is currently a hoarder, my sister is a “collector” . Her treasures might get sold one day. My middle sister buys things brand new but in many colors. Just in case she might need another. I am not a hoarder. I am deeply saddened with my mother’s situation and have not been in the house for awhile. I only watched 2 parts of the above story of My Mother’s Garden and it homes for me.

Catherine MacDonald June 14, 2009 at 10:48 am

Hi Julie! It must be tough to be a lonely voice of reason in a family of hoarders. I hope to hear your impressions of the rest of the documentary if you get a chance to finish watching it. (By the way, I have a policy of removing last names in to shield the privacy of the person making the comment. Hope you don’t mind!)

Mike M. June 24, 2009 at 4:52 am

I felt the frustration of the famliy members. I just started the same process last weekend at my Mothers house in Torrance, CA. The denial of the hoarding and resistance to help was overwhelming. My Mother has social services involved also. There are deadlines to be met and consequences if we cannot get her place cleaned up. This documentary shows it can be done. Thank you for making it available.

Catherine MacDonald June 24, 2009 at 8:18 am

Hi Mike :) Thank you so much for your comment. Starting in on such a big task is quite an undertaking. Who are you dealing with in Torrance, the Adult Protective Services people? Please email me (catherine@howtohelpahoarder.com) if you’d like a list of resources in your area — I’m compiling a master list now. Wishing you and your family all the best with this!

Suzie Q June 25, 2009 at 4:33 am

Having 5 siblings with little support I find the task daunting to deal with anger issues from by 81 year old mother – about issues when she was 7 – cannot let go of the past and expresses anger over what her mother did to try and put food on the table…stories go on and on. she is unable to let go of the past and it’s too late at her age to want to move forward and forgive(her words). Bitter about anyone having more that she did, and criticle of a daughter simply trying to help her. Always quick to blame, always quick to insult those trying to help. I am sure this is not uncommon. Neighbors would never know from the outside – nice lawn, nice yard – but inside – smell of rotting dead rodents, 9 or 10 small dogs running around out of control- too many to count, everytime I arrive – a new one appears – 2500+ SqFt house – and every room filled to the ceiling with ’stuff’. New shopping bags appear daily filled with the latest sale items – that ’someone may need’ – but no one in the family will ever have another infant – we’re too old, (baby clothes, craft items for grandkids that have already outgrown, 10,000 cookbooks and more…. How many tote bags can one have?). I’d give it all away free to someone willing to fight her for it. Sure – it’s an illness – but everytime I come back to my own home – I look for things I have I can donate to a worthy cause – as I do not ever want to be like that. Siblings unwilling to help, so, I am, therefore, ‘the bad guy’. So be it. This sickness needs to be treated before the sickness causes a fire or illness to someone. Her own neglect has been brought up by her doctor, her forgetfulness, and own safety risks – and has been turned over to her med group social service department for evaulation – that, she has told my siblings, is my fault, too. It will take a full year to clean out the house – this is no laughing matter – but she thinks it is funny to boobie trap every room and every drawer. “I” am having a hard time stepping foot into the house. I cannot stand the smell. ‘I’ manage her affairs. ‘I’ see people taking advange of her generostiy and loans. ‘I’ have been lied to by her and siblings about money issues and expected to find a way to keep her afloat. this is wearing on me and it’s taking it’s toll. ‘I’ am not willing to sit back and let her destroy her home and her life, and loose the only thing she has – her home. I have asked my siblings to step up – or else – the ultimatium is now on the table by social services – clean it up or it’s going to be tagged by the fire department. It’s out of my hands now, and my last resort is to intervien through the court system to take full control over her affairs. Seems like such a drastic measure, but I have little options. Thank YOU for the forum – I am sure there are worse stories than mine just waiting to be told.

Catherine MacDonald June 26, 2009 at 7:33 am

Hi Suzie, thank you very much for your note. You are going through an incredibly difficult time with this right now, and I really feel for you in this situation. It struck a deep chord with me when you said, “I am having a hard time stepping foot into the house.” That is such a natural, normal reaction to the situation in my opinion. I hope that you are able to find the resources there to help you with the practicalities of this situation. Is there a hoarding task force in your area by any chance?

Next week, Don Tagatac of Trauma Scene Cleaning Management Inc. in the NYC area has agreed to an interview to talk about what he does. Don’s company started in trauma scene cleanup but for several years now he has been working primarily in hoarding. Many people are not aware that there are biohazard cleanup companies like Don’s in most areas and that these companies do cleanups hoarded houses.

As we’re going to hear in the interview, Don takes it one step further with his company — he and his teams can actually work with someone who hoards to declutter a home step by step together.

But my point is that cleanup help is out there. Depending on cost and ability to pay, it is possible to get professional help with these huge crisis cleanouts that are so overwhelming.

I’ll be thinking of you and your mom — thank you so much for sharing your story, Suzie! Hope you keep us posted.

Ramona July 12, 2009 at 3:46 am

I too,am facing the fight of my life.My Mom @ 73 years old has very little room left in her house and also in a large out building. I am going to go over every inch of this website and try to put together a plan to help her. Thank you for all you do to help those of us in desperation.

Catherine MacDonald July 12, 2009 at 5:09 pm

Ramona, thank you so much for your comment! Please feel free to drop me a line at any time, catherine@howtohelpahoarder.com, if I can be of any assistance.

becki July 13, 2009 at 6:10 pm

I just got off the phone with my mother, a hoarder. The conversation ended in tears when I told her that her house keeps her from doing things she enjoys, she denied this, and then I reminded her of when we used to be able to come over for dinner about 15 years ago. I makes me so sad, the excuses, the blame, the “it doesn’t bother me”, “it’s not that bad”. The really insane part of it is she loves Clean Sweep and other organizing and cleaning shows, but doesn’t see herself as being as bad as the people on the show. It’s nice to know our family is not alone.

Catherine MacDonald July 14, 2009 at 5:42 pm

Hi Becki, thank you so much for your comment. It is truly sad, the situations our loved ones find themselves in, and the fact that they sometimes seem to value the status quo over time spent with their families.

Jolene July 18, 2009 at 4:21 am

I watched all the episodes. I felt like I was watching my own mother…She would fret knowing that my older sister was at the house when she was with me. My sister was very careful and mostly got rid of newspapers and literally “trash” The other items, she would “organize” for my mother to go through.
And myself. I remember crying – begging my husband to let me keep my mother’s stuff “for a while” after she passed away.
He did. I am slowly going through it myself. If someone else tries to “decide” for me then I come unglued – either outward or inward. It is very traumatic. I go into a depression.
I do not save trash; butter wrappers, cans, bottles, etc. I save usable things that I have enough of to take care of two families. My mother’s used tissues in her pockets were tempting, but I did get rid of them. (She always had a tissue in her pocket.)
So, where do we go from here…? I feel bad that the lady had to go to a nursing home and not to her own home again…but maybe that was best for her.

Martha July 18, 2009 at 7:09 am

This documentary is UNBELIEVABLE. At first, I wasn’t sure I wanted to watch the entire thing, it was so depressing and overwhelming (and hits a little too close to home). What strength and courage those kids had to do the right thing and help their mom. They were fairly well-adjusted (especially the daughter), considering what they grew up with.

This program was very well done, with outstanding narration and insight into the problem of hoarding. Unfortunately, I think it is much more common than people think. There are several members of my own family who have hoarding/”collecting” issues (myself included). It causes stress and tension for everyone involved and causes difficulties in relationships, to say nothing of the health and safety issues involved. I believe hoarding DOES run in families and is strongly tied to dementia/depression/OCD/ADD, etc. An important first step IS recognizing the problem and seeking help. It needs to be brought out into the open and talked about so that we can increase awareness and understanding of the disorder. Everyone needs hope, hoarders and their loved ones also.

Bravo to the Lester family for becoming healthier together– I thought Mom made amazing progress! I loved how she has gone on to caring for others and finding new purpose in her life. Thank you for sharing this documentary and for your site.

Catherine MacDonald July 20, 2009 at 8:48 am

Jolene – Thanks for your comment! I personally found the book “Buried in Treasures” really powerful in terms of helping to decide how to deal with items that may have sentimental appeal. Also Flylady — extremely helpful. When I couldn’t throw good stuff away, it helped to know that if I donated it I was “blessing” another family. My really good extra stuff went to the local battered women’s shelter — they were able to give it to women and children who had to rebuild their lives from scratch.

Martha, it is an amazing documentary isn’t it? And it brings up so many difficult emotions too. The daughter amazes me — so strong — and she was literally out on the street as a teen and yet she has such compassion for her mom. Thank you for your input!

Claudia July 25, 2009 at 6:29 pm

I started out to just watch one or two of the videos clips and ended up so rivited that I watched all of them straight thru.
My husband, whom I have lived with for 20 years, is a compulsive hoarder. I need to know where I can find mental health help to get to the bottom of the problem. I have tried cleaning out rooms resulting in his anger and re-filling the result. I do keep the main living areas free of clutter, but sometimes I just get so tired that I want to give up. Living with a hoarder is mentally, physically and emotionaly exhausting.
Any advice and help is greating appreciated.
Claudia

Peri Coke July 31, 2009 at 9:17 pm

Thank you so much for this documentary and the courage to share your story. My heart goes out to your mother and pray that she continues to flourish. I suspect much of her trouble is the loss that accompanied the horrible after affects of Hitler’s holocaust. The damage he did is still affecting generations.

Catherine MacDonald August 2, 2009 at 11:21 am

Claudia – Living with someone who hoards is indeed absolutely draining. You might find that it’s helpful to give a lot of thought about how you would ideally want to live. Also, you can think about what your limits are in terms of the home you share. What needs to be changed? When you know your ideal situation and also your limits, everything gets much clearer. Please stay tuned for some techniques for discussing the issues nonconfrontally with your spouse.

Peri – Thank you for your comment :) I am not the documentarian and this is not my story, but it truly is powerful isn’t it?

kailey August 12, 2009 at 2:29 am

My sister is a hoarder. It’s painful and confusing to see how she lives. It’s only now that I’m seeing that she is not unique. I’m surprised to see how many other people suffer from this and that it isn’t a choice. I feel for those who help whether they be family or professional help. it’s exhausting watching the film. It’s exhausting being in my sister’s company. Not only does she save things, she saves moments and memories, can’t leave a party or end a phone call. Now she photographs every moment. I wonder if the neighbors will turn her in someday. I’m not in a place to help her…but what are these people suppose to do?

L.G. August 13, 2009 at 2:04 am

I must add that her sister has been helping her go through clean out and pack up boxes over the past SEVERAL weeks not making much progress but a little. That is why the garage is filling up…(one little back room of items and some items that came out of the old garage before they tore it down). Future garage sale items.. in the mean time she has 5 other rooms the kitchen & bathroom that need attention … I try to help if I can but unsuccessfully… I pray that something the family has said to her will effect her and help her let go… One person just can’t undo 30+ years of saving very quickly. Any tips you could suggest would be great!

Leave a Comment

Previous post: Is It Hoarding?

Next post: Free Q&A Conference Call